Will Asean’s ₱23-B treatment work?

Will Asean’s ₱23-B treatment work?
Asean leaders meet with representatives of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations Business Advisory Council in Manila on Nov. 15.—PHOTO FROM THE PRESIDENTIAL COMMUNICATIONS OFFICE

In medicine we have a blunt rule for expensive tests: A workup is justified only if its result changes what we do for the patient. A full-body scan that changes nothing is not diligence. It is waste with good lighting.

The 49th Asean Summit, which closes in Manila this week as the chairmanship passes to Singapore, deserves the same test. The Philippines has spent close to ₱23 billion on a year of hosting. The honest question is not whether the summit looked impressive. It is whether it will change the condition of the patient—the Filipino people and the region—in ways we can measure a year from now.

The bill and its dose-response curve

The hosting budget totals about ₱22.9 billion, spread across the 2025 and 2026 budgets. The 2026 appropriation alone is ₱17.49 billion, of which ₱10.78 billion went to the Office of the President. That is roughly ₱200 for every Filipino.

The trend is steep. The national government spent about ₱1 billion to host Asean leaders in 2007. The 2017 chairmanship was allocated some ₱15.5 billion to ₱17 billion. Malacañang says this year covers more than 550 meetings, against 279 in 2017, and that every peso will be audited.

The 2017 precedent is the most useful clinical history we have. Of the ₱11.07 billion given to the Office of the President then, only 34%—₱3.79 billion—was actually used. The Commission on Audit also found some ₱757 million it could not audit because documents were incomplete. 

In other words, the dose was far higher than the treatment needed, and part of what was given cannot be accounted for. A doctor who prescribed that way would face a review board.

Surrogate markers vs hard endpoints

Cardiology learned the hard way that improving a surrogate marker does not always save lives. Some drugs lowered a number on the lab sheet and still failed to prevent heart attacks. Summits have their own surrogate markers: joint statements, photo lines and the count of documents adopted. These matter, but these are not outcomes.

To be fair, the chairmanship has some real results. The Cebu summit in May amended the Asean Charter for the first time since 2007 to admit Timor-Leste as a full member. Last Saturday, ministers signed the Digital Economy Framework Agreement (Defa), the first region-wide pact of its kind, expected to take effect in early 2027. Manila also brokered talks between Thailand and Cambodia after their border clashes.

The primary endpoint, however, was the South China Sea Code of Conduct. Asean and China set themselves a 2026 deadline in 2023. Officials now describe the text as about 70–80% complete, and no final code is expected at this summit. 

Beijing has long resisted making it legally binding. If the talks continue, they continue under Singapore. A trial that misses its primary endpoint can still produce useful secondary findings, but no honest research investigator calls it a success.

2 populations to immunize

Goodwill behaves like immunity from a vaccine. A single dose produces a response, but protection wanes without boosters. The warmth leaders feel in Manila this week will fade within months unless it is renewed through follow-through: agreements implemented, promises kept, and visits returned.

There are two populations to immunize. The first is our neighbors and dialogue partners, among whom the Philippines has gained standing as a convener and peace broker. The second is our own people. Businesses near the summit venue were temporarily closed, roads were shut, and families who struggle with rising prices watched billions of pesos spent on hospitality. 

The Pasay City government cleared Baclaran of street vendors ahead of the Asean Summit.—PHOTO FROM PASAY CITY PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICE FB PAGE

The President has said the benefits will far outweigh these inconveniences. That claim is reasonable, but it is a prognosis, not a result, and the public is entitled to see it confirmed.

Goodwill with China, the most important and most difficult relationship, is the least assured. An unfinished code of conduct means the underlying condition remains untreated. 

We have managed the symptoms; we have not reversed the disease.

The aftercare plan

In heart failure, many hard-won gains in the hospital are lost in the weeks after the patient is discharged, when follow-up lapses and medicines are stopped. The same risk now faces the chairmanship. 

Here is the aftercare we would prescribe, with health at its center.

1. Issue a discharge summary within 90 days. Publish an itemized account of the ₱22.9 billion: what was spent, on what, and what remains unused. Instruct the Commission on Audit to release its findings promptly, not years later as in 2017.

2. Reinvest the savings in health. If, as in 2017, a large share goes unspent, Congress should put an equal amount into the 2027 budget for primary care and for PhilHealth coverage of indigent members. Money budgeted for hospitality should come back as hospital care.

3. Keep the summit’s health capacity. Hosting more than 20 heads of state requires emergency medical teams, surveillance and rapid response. Whatever was assembled for the summit should remain as permanent mass-gathering and emergency capacity for Metro Manila, rather than disbanding on Wednesday.

4. Claim a real role in regional outbreak defense. Asean is operationalizing its Center for Public Health Emergencies and Emerging Diseases. The Philippines, an archipelago exposed to every regional outbreak, should secure a strong role in its surveillance and laboratory networks.

5. Make the digital pact serve patients. Defa was negotiated mainly for trade, but its rules on data flows and digital trust can support cross-border telemedicine, electronic prescriptions and the safe exchange of health records. The Department of Health should be at the table when the rules are implemented.

6. Turn the “silver economy” into healthy aging. The Philippines championed an Asean framework on the silver economy. An older person cannot stay productive with uncontrolled blood pressure or diabetes. The framework should be anchored on noncommunicable disease prevention, already a priority of the Asean Strategic Health Agenda 2026–2030.

7. Register the endpoints. Clinical trials must register their outcomes in advance so results cannot be spun later. Every chairmanship deliverable should be listed publicly, with an owner and a date, and reported at 12 and 24 months. That is how goodwill gets its boosters.                                                              

The verdict

Was it worth ₱23 billion? The fair answer today is that we do not yet know, and that the answer depends on what happens after the leaders fly home. Diplomacy is not free, and a country that will not host cannot expect to lead. But the 2017 record shows the same work can be done for far less, and the code of conduct, the summit’s main goal, remains unfinished.

Our prognosis is guarded, not grim. The patient leaves the hospital stable, with real but modest gains. Whether those gains last depends on aftercare. 

If the government publishes its accounts, returns the savings to the health of Filipinos, and follows through on its commitments, the summit will have been a sound investment. If not, it will be remembered as a very expensive scan that changed nothing. CS

Dr. Rafael R. Castillo is a cardiologist, educator, and public health advocate. He was president of the Philippine Heart Association (PHA), the Philippine Society of Hypertension and the Asian Pacific Society of Hypertension, and was a longtime health columnist of the Inquirer. He now writes the weekly ‘Pulse Check’ column for the Philippine Star. He has over 45 awards to his name, including the PHA Lifetime Achievement Award, and continues to champion preventive cardiology and public health reforms here and abroad.