Duterte lawyers’ ‘super expert’ witness irks senator-judges

Rainer Dela Fuente
Lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente takes the witness stand on the defense's fifth day of presentation at Vice President Sara Duterte's impeachment trial. —PHOTO BY BULLIT MARQUEZ-SPPA POOL

Several senator-judges accused Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team of wasting the impeachment court’s time on Thursday, Nov. 19, after their “super expert” witness, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) official, admitted his testimony was purely “hypothetical.”

The team presented lawyer Rainer Dela Fuente to refute the House prosecution-commissioned forensic analysis report that the vice president and her husband, Manases Carpio, had amassed over P800 million in unexplained wealth.

But Dela Fuente found himself on the defensive after acknowledging that he had not read the actual forensic audit report prepared by lawyer-certified public accountant Alexander Cabrera, relying instead on “snippets” presented to him by defense lawyer Mark Vinluan.

He contradicted himself when he noted that drawing up a financial audit report in two weeks, as Vinluan claimed Cabrera did, was possible, though challenging. Later, the witness testified that he could see the problems immediately when the defense team showed portions of the forensic report.

This admission prompted Senator-Judge Francis Pangilinan to ask him about this contradiction.

‘Hypothetical’ questions

Dela Fuente said Vinluan’s questions were “hypothetical” and “it’s not about the full (forensic audit) report.”

“So therefore, if the question is hypothetical, you can answer it?” Pangilinan asked him, adding, “What’s the probative value of your testimony if you answer hypothetically in an impeachment trial where we look at evidence and determine the law applicable based on evidence?”

The witness said he was called to testify “on the Anti-Money Laundering standards and how financial investigation is usually conducted.”

Pangilinan then asked Dela Fuente’s comment about his ability to “provide legal opinion or analyze whether an act was within the bounds of the law.”

“How will you know if this is within the bounds of the law if u don’t know the facts?” the senator-judge said, prompting Dela Fuente to say that the questions he was asked at the hearing were “limited only to hypothetical questions.”

“We both went to law school. We are used to recitations. When we recite, we need to apply the law based on the facts. If our professor called us for recitation and asked us, ‘What is the law, or recite the case of People vs. etc.’ Can you tell the professor that I didn’t read the case or the decision, but I can give my comments? If that’s the case, what will be your grade?” Pangilinan asked. Dela Fuente replied: “Failed.”

Pangilinan told the impeachment court: “[H]e’s admitted that his manifestations are all hypothetical, and therefore we should be guided accordingly.”

On the fifth day of the defense team’s presentation of witnesses against the sole article of impeachment — which accuses Duterte of amassing illegal wealth and failing to declare assets in her statements of assets, liabilities, and net worth (SALNs), it sought anew to discredit Cabrera’s forensic report, only for both the prosecution and senator-judges to question the witness’ credentials.

Flashing flames

But sparks literally flew before the impeachment trial began when, during Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano’s opening prayer before the court, red flames flashed through the Senate livestream.

The court’s presiding officer, Francis Escudero, called out the Senate Public Relations and Information Bureau (PRIB), the unit in-charge of the livestream: “The flames are not well-taken and inappropriate to these proceedings.”

“Kindly remove or edit it from the records of the impeachment court as it is deemed inappropriate,” Escudero said.

In a statement, the PRIB apologized “for the accidental transition effect” and said that it was due to an “unexpected technical issue during the broadcast, which we deeply regret.”

“PRIB is currently upgrading its equipment and undergoing training and upskilling of its technical staff in a bid to strengthen the quality of broadcast media coverage for the Filipino people,” it said, committing to a “responsible, transparent and credible broadcast media coverage of all Senate proceedings.”

Presenting Dela Fuente, Vinluan told the impeachment court the lawyer is an expert in financial investigation, particularly in anti-money laundering, having worked at the AMLC from 2015 to 2018, and was assigned cases, investigated them, and produced reports that law enforcement agencies could use. 

Dela Fuente defined money laundering as using the financial system to mask illicit activities. After AMLC, he opened a law firm from 2019 to 2021, and established a consultancy in 2021 to help people covered by the Anti-Money Laundering Act (Amla) comply with its regulations.

House public prosecutor Chel Diokno questioned Vinluan’s line of questioning, particularly on anti-money laundering, when he stressed that the prosecution did not charge the vice president with that offense in the articles of impeachment. 

But Escudero ruled that Diokno could question this during his cross-examination of the witness.

AMLC records

Vinluan’s series of questions prompted objections from Diokno after the defense lawyer asked about “the propriety of a third person,” such as Cabrera, accessing and analyzing AMLC records, including the vice president’s bank statements.

Under Section 8-a of Amla, he said, “This role of doing financial investigation is expressly reserved to AMLC … I have no other information that allows it outside AMLC.”

Vinluan continued with questions linking Article II of the impeachment case with money laundering. But Diokno objected to the “misleading” question, making it clear that money laundering was not part of the substantive charges against Duterte. 

Diokno said the “main issue” of Article II was “whether the vice president had unexplained wealth, whether she did not declare certain assets in her SALN, and whether she participated in business while holding office.”

Escudero, though, overruled Diokno’s objections, saying, “Let’s see where it goes.” But Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo interjected after Vinluan asked the witness about the strength of allegations against a person if cases had been withdrawn, and then presented a video of the late Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago, where she was scolding House prosecutors during the 2011 impeachment trial of the late Chief Justice Renato Corona for withdrawing articles of impeachment filed against him. 

“What is the relevance of all this, Mr. Presiding Officer? We’re like watching a movie. And another thing: Pagpahingahin natin ang namayapa. This is a different case; this is a different set of senators … I really don’t understand why are we watching this?” Tulfo asked.

Escudero agreed, noting he was about to ask the defense panel to pause the video.

Senator-judge Panfilo Lacson said he “could not see the significance of the opinion of one of the 24 senator-judges” in the Corona impeachment trial in the current trial against Duterte.

Senator-judge Risa Hontiveros objected to the video footage presentation of Santiago and that of Corona himself, which Vinluan had played in court, showing the late Chief Justice testifying about how the impeachment trial had deeply affected him and his family. 

Equally, Hontiveros also thumbed down the defense’s playing of video footage of former President Rodrigo Duterte saying he would not file an impeachment case against then Vice President Leni Robredo.

Without mentioning their names, she referred to Santiago and Corona having long passed away, while Duterte, who is in The Hague for the crimes against humanity case before the International Criminal Court, was not in the country. 

Hontiveros said the impeachment court judges could not speak to them. “This kind of situation is not fair to these people who were shown in the videos. It’s also not fair for the Senate impeachment court.”

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo also interjected, saying Corona was convicted in his impeachment trial. “Let me remind you, CJ Corona was impeached because he did not state the truth on his SALN,” he said.

Claims of confidentiality

Diokno objected to Vinluan’s questioning of the witness’ opinion on the confidentiality of the financial and bank records used in the forensic audit report. He reminded that the impeachment court had rejected “claims of confidentiality” and accepted documents from AMLC.

Pangilinan told the defense panel to raise its complaint to the Supreme Court “if they wish to question the impeachment court’s ruling on the confidentiality of the AMLC records.”

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo questioned Dela Fuente’s expertise again after Vinluan started to ask the witness about the amici curiae, or friends of the court, invited by the impeachment court previously, to give their stand on the voting threshold required for conviction.

“Who is this guy? I’m really, very, very curious about the qualifications of this gentleman, as he could answer all the topics asked of him by his handler, or excuse me, by the defense,” Tulfo quipped.

Sen. Bam Aquino asked Dela Fuente if the defense had given him a copy of, or if he had seen, the forensic audit report, bank records, and financial statements subpoenaed to the impeachment court and used as the basis in Cabrera’s analysis. Dela Fuente said he has not seen copies.

Aquino then pointed out that the witness testimony was more on “concepts and general ideas on Amla and financial investigation,” prompting Vinluan to say that they showed Dela Fuente “portions” of the report, too, so they could confront him in open court.

Aquino said the impeachment court has many witnesses who would testify they did not know some details and “we want witnesses who can testify on specific matters.”

‘Zero knowledge’

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo noted that the witness has “zero knowledge” about the forensic report and should not refute it. “The problem is on the defense because they believed that you can refute it,” he added.

Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo asked the value of the witness’ testimony if he did not read the report, noting that the latter’s statements have all been “theoretical.” He told the defense: “You can do better than that. Get a witness who can really stand up … and answer questions of senator-judges. The witnesses you have presented in the past few days are weak.”

On Hontiveros’ questioning, Dela Fuente explained that he did not review Duterte and Carpio’s financial or bank statements “because these are confidential.” The senator said the witness was “not in a solid position to analyze the quality or even general principles.” 

Dela Fuente disagreed, saying, “I echo what the law says. Just based on the law, I can say whether it’s lawful or not.” He added: “I don’t need to read the full report even before going here, because I could see if the (findings) are aligned with Amla.”

Upon direct examination by Vinluan, he said Duterte’s suspicious transactions and covered transactions in the AMLC report were “not actual proof” of wrongdoing but were “indicators.” He said: “They invite scrutiny. Many STRs are false positives. It just gives AMLC a signal (to investigate).”

During cross-examination, House prosecutor Diokno got Dela Fuente to admit he spent 25 months as an entry-level financial investigator at AMLC. The witness said he had a “brief but meaningful” stint at AMLC.

To Escudero, the witness said he was not there to counter the conclusions of Cabrera’s report but to see whether this was done “within the bounds of the law.” Asked if Cabrera violated any law in his report, the witness said the impeachment court will make this determination.

Escudero asked whether Cabrera violated any law as per the portions of the report shown to him. Dela Fuente said the forensic expert violated the confidentiality rule as cited in Amla.

Diokno then asked if Dela Fuente was saying the bank and financial records used by Cabrera are inaccurate, and the latter replied in the negative. He gave the same remark when Diokno asked whether the Bureau of Internal Revenue and the Securities and Exchange Commission’s records were tampered with or incorrect.

In an exchange, too, with Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo, who questioned his ability to give expert opinion without reading the report, Dela Fuente said that even in his short stint at AMLC, he could see that “in just one look, I could see the problems.”

“Wow, You’re like a supercomputer. You’re like ChatGPT,” Tulfo shot back. CS

Read more: On the 4th day, VP Duterte’s team focuses on her husband’s spending